Editorial 'A Star has fallen' in LAW ANIMATED WORLD, 15-31 May 2009 Summer Special issue

A STAR HAS FALLEN

                                                                              Praba        with                                                              

 

 

 

 

 

                                      Fallen Prabakaran                                         Dwaraka , Mathivathani & Balachandran

VELUPPILLAI PRABHAKARAN is no more. Amidst utter anguish and disbelief we are constrained to acknowledge that at last the star of Sri Lankan Tamil Eelam has fallen. Not just the leader but his entire family – including wife Mathivathani, daughter Dwaraka, sons: 24-year old Charles Anthony and the 11-year old Balachandran – has been vengefully wiped out in a gory passion of barbaric vendetta by the ‘civilized’ Sinhalese who gave a public assurance that they would hand over the bodies to an undertaker and not just throw them into the seas. But ultimately a Sri Lankan General asserts that Prabakaran was cremated and his ashes thrown into the sea. Oh how can they do that – and that to a virtual Head-of-State!? The UN, its Human Rights Council, the International Red Cross and the Norwegian peace-brokers – where have they all gone? Has the LTTE not several times, even if not regularly, handed over the bodies of the Sinhalese dead to the Red Cross? Even the worst dictators have not acted in this maniac fashion it seems – why, the dead body of Zulifqar Ali Bhutto had been flown to Larkana and a mausoleum allowed to be built there which turned to be a centre of pilgrimage and of democratic resistance to the military rule. This one incident is sufficient to show how cruelly the Sri Lankan regime has trampled upon the basic human rights of Sri Lankan Tamils and indulged in a terrible genocide. A hero of a people has been treated worse than a beggar on the street and deliberately humiliated. Not just the Tamils but no civilized community on earth can ever tolerate such enormous war crime which is but one stupendous sin amidst hundreds of such others taking a toll of nearly 20,000 civilian lives in just a few months of the final battles. While paying our reverent homage to this intrepid martyr, we demand a habeas corpus from the international community and also that it wake up at least now and try the Sri Lankan regime for war crimes in an International Court of Law §§§

Editorial: "Electoral Equations and Eelam" in 30 April 2009 issue of LAW

ELECTORAL EQUATIONS AND EELAM

Prabakaran

Will his be the last laugh?

KK

Jayalalitha Vaiko

A poet had so beautifully put it that ‘in the womb of every defeat lies hidden a victory’. This exactly seems to be the case with the much hunted LTTE leader Prabakaran. Precisely when on the brink of total defeat and possible capture/death, his popularity has shot to meteoric heights. It may not be an exaggeration to say that he is the most charismatic and popular figure in Tamil Nadu today and the entire Tamil Nadu politics, especially in the background of the coming parliamentary elections in May, is revolving round the horrible plight of Sri Lankan Tamils and the tragic situation of the LTTE facing complete liquidation exacerbated by the sting of Sri Lankan victory howls which cut at the self-respect of Tamils all over the world. Leaders of the like of Ramadas, founder of PMK, have likened him to Netaji and lauded him as a great freedom fighter. Truly one man’s terrorist is another man’s freedom fighter, and that is why and how, despite the grave blunders and excesses by himself and the LTTE, Prabakaran has become the apple of the eye of a majority of Tamils. And today, even Jayalalitha, once bitterly opposed to the LTTE and herself hunted by them, turned a strong supporter of Tamil Eelam, of course election gimmicks forming a big part of her passion. And Karunanidhi should be reminiscing his days of rapport with Periyar and the good old Dravidanadu campaigns. We already know Vaiko of MDMK being a great fan of Prabakaran. Earlier once we had already cautioned that unless something urgent and meaningful is done for relieving the impasse of Sri Lankan Tamils and the mindset blaming LTTE for everything is changed, Tamil Nadu itself may burn in future. Prabakaran live or dead is going to be a big problem for India and wisdom lies in keeping him alive and free and try negotiate and settle with him. We reiterate the same lest the Tamils all over the world, in no distant future, should look to shift the demand, location and flames of Eelam to Tamil Nadu itself §§§

Editorial: "Make It Fundamental" of 15 April 2009 issue of LAW ANIMATED WORLD

MAKE IT FUNDAMENTAL!

May be startling but it is true that, albeit a constitutional provision that elections to parliament and assemblies are to be on the basis of adult suffrage, the right of universal and equal adult franchise through secret ballot is not a fundamental right in our constitution – this despite the clear assertion in Article 21 (3) of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights 1948 that “The will of the people … shall be expressed in periodic and genuine elections which shall be by universal and equal suffrage and shall be held by secret vote or by equivalent free voting procedure” and the initial discussions, though scanty, in our Constituent Assembly to make it a fundamental right. Also no amendments to that extent were tried even later though the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights 1966 [ratified by India in 1979] also declared that “[25(2). Every citizen shall have the right and the opportunity …] to vote and to be elected at genuine periodic elections which shall be by universal and equal suffrage and shall be held by secret ballot, guranteeing the freedom of expression and will of the electors.” We find many drawbacks in our election system stifling the people’s free choice to elect and get elected. An arbitrarily appointed Election Commission is vested with wide discretionary (say near-arbitrary) powers and the courts are prohibited to intervene whatever the blunders committed by it until after the elections. Several thousand persons, with voter identity cards even, do not find place in the electoral rolls, but no remedy is available to them as superior courts refuse to intervene except in case of ‘by way of election petition after elections’; also genuine electors barred to contest election due to capricious rejection of nomination forms on hyper-technical grounds have nowhere to go for immediate relief. But if the right to vote be made fundamental, the superior courts would be in duty bound to conduct judicial review and reach requisite immediate justice. Hence we want such right to be made a fundamental one and we have no doubt that this demand will get widespread support. §§§

Correction in Title

Martyrs Memorial Special issue it should be. Sorry for the mistake - IMS.

Editorial TO PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION of 15-31 March 2009 Martyra Memorial Special issue of Law Animated World

To Proportional Representation

we must switch over if we really want to curb, totally eliminate may be too tall a wish, money-power and criminalization of politics perverting our democratic system. The much vaunted Constitution we have is largely copied from the infamous Government of India Act 1935, which in itself distortedly reflected the plurality voting system of Great Britain. It is the colonial legacy which resulted in our adhesion to this not-so-happy electoral system, where the legitimate claims of various sections of the people are blissfully neglected. A party securing even 30-35% of the popular vote can win all or most of the posts and an opposition with around 25% votes may not secure even 10-20% of the seats, and less favoured ones with 10-20% or less, but with considerable support from weaker sections or minorities, may draw a mere cipher. This cannot be called really representative democracy and defeats the very ideals of justice - social, political and economic, and of democratic governance, adumbrated in our Constitution. For example, the Madiga Reservation Porata Samiti (MRPS), which has now decided to contest independently in the state of Andhra Pradesh, may bag around 10% of vote in the coming elections but get no seats, whereas the communist parties which together may not get more than 5-6% of popular vote may secure 8-10 Assembly plus 2-4 Lok Sabha seats thanks to their alliance and the present first-past-the-post system. This surely cannot be called just or equitable. There is something like ethical equality which may be more precious than mere political equality. Even in the U.K., Northern Ireland and Wales Legislatures have opted for proportional systems; and Ireland and Scotland are already in that category. Only some 45-50 out of the 200 odd countries of the world adopt this plurality system whereas many of the most developed democracies in Europe as well as South Africa and New Zealand follow the proportional system. Whether it should be by the party-list method or Single Trnasferable Vote, etc. can be worked out, but we feel it is high time that people here think, discuss and overcome the current inherited inertia and bring a salutary change in the electoral system of the country. To begin with we may opt for partial proportionality and experiment it in a few states before making it countrywide. This change would certainly be the harbinger of a genuine socio-economic change for the betterment of the common man and achievement of social justice §§§

Editorial in LAW ANIMATED WORLD, 28 February 2009 issue: FIGHT TO THE FINISH?

FIGHT TO THE FINISH?

It is really sad that the UN Security Council also refused to actively intervene in Sri Lanka but, on the contrary, the SC members appealed to the LTTE to release the civilians virtually taken hostage by them and also to lay down their arms and abandon the use of violence to pursue their political aims. Of course, they have also appealed to the Sri Lankan Government to exercise maximum restraint but nobody questioned the declared Sri Lankan position of fighting the civil war to the finish and soon eliminating the LTTE. Actually none of the Security Council members was prepared even to propose a request for a ceasefire. Even the briefing by John Holmes, the UN Under-Secretary-General for Humanitarian Affairs, on the shocking humanitarian crisis in Sri Lanka was at first opposed by Russia, which was afraid that if she agrees to a sovereign State of the UN being questioned in its campaign to suppress an internal insurgency, then tomorrow she herself may be dragged to the international forum on the Chechnya problem, which is no less alarming. Unfortunately for Prabakaran and the LTTE, they have ‘overstretched’ themselves and earned a bad name in international circles, being branded as a terrorist organization even by the European Union, doubtless a very liberal democratic entity. However, Sri Lanka led by Mahinda Rajapaksa should also realize that the Bush doctrine of ‘fight to an end’ is not that easy, given the LTTE’s tenacity and daring to mount surprise suicidal attacks. Further, even if the lions win and tigers vanquished, the guerilla war may not stop. It seems there are saner elements in the LTTE circles also, some of them speaking highly of the now-opposition leader, former Premier, Ranil Wickremasinghe, and so we feel Sri Lankan Government should be magnanimous in victory and, instead of pushing for fight to the finish, declare immediate ceasefire and negotiate with the LTTE and other Tamil forces to work out a peaceful federal solution in Sri Lanka §§§

Editorial in LAW ANIMATED WORLD, 15 February 2009 issue: TAMILS IN TURMOIL

TAMILS IN TURMOIL

now all over the world, but especially in Sri Lanka and also in Tamil Nadu, over the gory plight of the Tamils there bearing the brunt of the military offensive launched by the Sri Lankan Army to totally decimate the dreaded Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam, fighting for a separate homeland for Tamils. Sri Lankan forces seem to have gained a clear upper hand and captured all the important LTTE bases including their bastion Mullaittivu and are now poised for the final strike against their last stronghold Puthukkuduyiruppu. From November 2006 onwards the SL military operations with terrific airstrikes and intensive shelling have not only devastated the LTTE ranks but also resulted in thousands of civilian casualties; even school children and hospital patients were and are not spared and the Tamils all over the world are furious that it is but a campaign of genocide and ethnic cleansing. Large protest demonstrations have taken place and are being held worldwide by the Tamil diaspora but especially Tamil Nadu is in intense agitation. At least three fanatic admirers of LTTE, and votaries of Tamil Eelam, beginning with Muthukumar, immolated themselves castigating not only SL chauvinists but also ‘Indian Imperialism’ and now LTTE flags and portraits of the iconic leader Prabakaran are being displayed openly in defiance of all anti-terrorist law. One can understand the intense anguish behind such protests since there have been and are close relations between Tamils across the sea, and Tamil Nadu has seen the origin of an ‘independent Dravid Nadu’ campaign as far back as in the 1950s even before any Eelam agitation was conceived in Sri Lanka. Truly the human tragedy in Sri Lanka is of staggering proportions and there is urgent need for the international community to immediately cause a cease fire and also restart of peaceful negotiations to solve the Sri Lankan ethnic problem. India should also actively intervene in the matter lest in not distant future our own South starts burning too §§§