Saturday, September 22, 2007

DON'T DESTROY THE ECO-HERITAGE!





EDITORIAL 15 SEPTEMBER 2007 LAW ANIMATED WORLD


Don’t destroy the eco-heritage!







It may be called Rama Setu or Adam’s Bridge; people may really believe Lord Ram and his monkey army built it or that Adam passed over it to meditate on the Adam’s peak. Or may be as Karunanidhi lambasts it is just a piece of fiction from a myth that allegorically reflected the conflict between the Aryans and the Dravidians and Rama himself is but an imaginary character. But the point here is all experts agree that it is a chain of limestone shoals and coral reefs. All admit that it took several thousands of years for such a formation to emerge and it actually might have bridged the mainland with Sri Lanka a few thousands of years ago. The shallow waters now might have later engulfed this geological formation. And in the not-too-remote Tsunami disaster that devastated Nagapattinam and many other places in South India this natural barrier had effectively protected the southern shores of Kerala from its ravages. Moreover the Sri Lankan Government seems to be dead set against the destruction of this natural barrier through dredging. In such circumstances we also feel and opine it would not be wise or proper for the Government of India to go whole hog with the Setusamudram Project in the name of cutting down shipping expenses in future. Critics also see and decry American and multinational machinations in pushing forward this immensely costly project destroying our natural heritage. It is heartening to note that our Supreme Court has intervened by staying all dredging operations in connection with the project pending disposal of some cases before it. Hope the people in a non-communal and eco-protective manner exert the needed pressure on both the Central and Tamil Nadu Governments to desist from such destruction and explore alternative eco-friendly options for the Setusamudram Project ¨¨¨


DON'T DESTROY THE ECO-HERITAGE!

A world law fortnightly published from Hyderabad, India.
Editor: I. Mallikarjuna Sharma
ADVISORY BOARD: Dr. Lakshmi Sahgal (INA Colonel), V.R. Krishna Iyer (Former Judge, SC), B.P. Jeevan Reddy (Former Judge, SC), P.A. Choudary (Former Judge, APHC), Surendra Mohan (Ex-MP), Prof. R.V.R. Chandrasekhara Rao (Politics), Umesh Chandra (Senior Advocate, Lucknow), Colin Gonsalves (Senior Advocate, Delhi), K. Subba Rao (Senior Advocate, Bangalore), K.G. Kannabiran (Senior Advocate & National President, PUCL), Ms. Chandan Ramamurthi (Advocate, Delhi).
Volume 3: Part 2 15 September 2007 No. 17
C O N T E N T S
1. Don’t destroy the eco-heritage! 1
2. Law News: Global Fishing Crisis 2
3. Human Rights violations by USA 3-6
4. Rowlatt Report 7-8, 57-58
5. CRC Report 9-10, 55-56
6. DPP v. T O'Regan [IRE-SC] 11-26
7. DPP v. Willoughby [IRE-CCA] 27-41
8. DPP v. Cronin [IRE-SC] 42-54
9. To Build a Fire, Jack London 59-61
10. Oh, Public! Anton Chekov 62-63
11. Poems by Pash 64
Pictures: Rama Setu or Adam’s Bridge, by courtesy of Google Images, NASA and Manitham, respectively.
Editorial Office: 6-3-1243/156, M.S. Makta, Opposite Raj Bhavan, Hyderabad - 500 082 (Ph: 23300284)E-mail: malliksharma@yahoo.com ; Film making: VSS Laser Graphics, Hyderabad - 500004 {Ph: 55365979};
Printed at Pragati Offset Pvt. Ltd., Red Hills, Hyderabad-4. (Ph: 23304835)
Annual Subscription: Rs. 700/- Abroad: $ 120 (postage extra)
Life Subscription: Rs. 8000/-
Payments to be sent by Cheque/DD/ MO in favour of LAW ANIMATED WORLD at 6-3-1243/156, M.S. Makta, Opp. Raj Bhavan, Hyderabad-500082.
[Please add Rs. 50/- for outstation cheques]
Don’t destroy the eco-heritage!








It may be called Rama Setu or Adam’s Bridge; people may really believe Lord Ram and his monkey army built it or that Adam passed over it to meditate on the Adam’s peak. Or may be as Karunanidhi lambasts it is just a piece of fiction from a myth that allegorically reflected the conflict between the Aryans and the Dravidians and Rama himself is but an imaginary character. But the point here is all experts agree that it is a chain of limestone shoals and coral reefs. All admit that it took several thousands of years for such a formation to emerge and it actually might have bridged the mainland with Sri Lanka a few thousands of years ago. The shallow waters now might have later engulfed this geological formation. And in the not-too-remote Tsunami disaster that devastated Nagapattinam and many other places in South India this natural barrier had effectively protected the southern shores of Kerala from its ravages. Moreover the Sri Lankan Government seems to be dead set against the destruction of this natural barrier through dredging. In such circumstances we also feel and opine it would not be wise or proper for the Government of India to go whole hog with the Setusamudram Project in the name of cutting down shipping expenses in future. Critics also see and decry American and multinational machinations in pushing forward this immensely costly project destroying our natural heritage. It is heartening to note that our Supreme Court has intervened by staying all dredging operations in connection with the project pending disposal of some cases before it. Hope the people in a non-communal and eco-protective manner exert the needed pressure on both the Central and Tamil Nadu Governments to desist from such destruction and explore alternative eco-friendly options for the Setusamudram Project ¨¨¨

DOUSE THE NUCLEAR FIRE!

EDITORIAL 31 AUGUST 2007 LAW

A world law fortnightly published from Hyderabad, India.
Editor: I. Mallikarjuna Sharma
ADVISORY BOARD: Dr. Lakshmi Sahgal (INA Colonel), V.R. Krishna Iyer (Former Judge, SC), B.P. Jeevan Reddy (Former Judge, SC), P.A. Choudary (Former Judge, APHC), Surendra Mohan (Ex-MP), Prof. R.V.R. Chandrasekhara Rao (Politics), Umesh Chandra (Senior Advocate, Lucknow), Colin Gonsalves (Senior Advocate, Delhi), K. Subba Rao (Senior Advocate, Bangalore), K.G. Kannabiran (Senior Advocate & National President, PUCL), Ms. Chandan Ramamurthi (Advocate, Delhi).
Volume 3: Part 2 31 August 2007 No. 16
C O N T E N T S
1. Douse the Nuclear Fire! 1
2. Bhagat Singh Birth Centenary 2, 59
3. Section 123 of AEA, 1954 3-7
4. Non-Proliferation Treaty 8-11
5. Operation Paget Inquiry Report (on Diana Death) 11-14, 51-52
6. Rowlatt Report 15-16, 45-46
7. CRC Report 17-18, 43-44
8. Constitutional Complaint by Ms. K … [GER-FCC] 19-42
9. Human Rights violations by US 47-50
10. To Build a Fire, Jack London 53-58
11. Poems by Robert Burns 60
Pictures: 1. 14 kiloton nuclear explosion, US (1951); 2. The Nagasaki Nuke (1945); 3. Chinese H-Bomb test; 4. Our ‘Smiling Buddha’ crater (Pokharan, 1974).
Editorial Office: 6-3-1243/156, M.S. Makta, Opposite Raj Bhavan, Hyderabad - 500 082 (Ph: 23300284)E-mail: malliksharma@yahoo.com ; Film making: VSS Laser Graphics, Hyderabad - 500004 {Ph: 55365979};
Printed at Pragati Offset Pvt. Ltd., Red Hills, Hyderabad-4. (Ph: 23304835)
Annual Subscription: Rs. 700/- Abroad: $ 120 (postage extra)
Life Subscription: Rs. 8000/-
Payments to be sent by Cheque/DD/ MO in favour of LAW ANIMATED WORLD at 6-3-1243/156, M.S. Makta, Opp. Raj Bhavan, Hyderabad-500082.
[Please add Rs. 50/- for outstation cheques]
DOUSE THE NUCLEAR FIRE!



3



1 2 4
In the bustle and din surrounding the 123 Agreement by Bush and Man, many in India seem to have forgotten the Hiroshima Day (August 6) and the pledge of all peace lovers in the world to actively work against nuclear weaponization and for complete disarmament. One ought to remember that “the first and only nuclear weapons used in war destroyed two cities killing more than 2,00,000 people by the end of 1945. The radiation … continues to cause cancers, mutations, and birth defects [to this day].” Also that “over the six decades of the nuclear age, every site worldwide, involved in the mining, milling, production and fabrication of uranium, for either weapons or ‘peaceful’ energy, has left a lethal legacy of radioactive waste, illness, and damage to our genetic heritage. Indigenous and colonized people have borne a disproportionate share of the suffering …. Plutonium, created by burning uranium fuel …, stays radioactive for more than 250,000 years and we still haven't figured out how to safely contain it. So-called ‘depleted’ uranium metal, a by-product …, has been manufactured into armaments used by the U.S. …, spreading illness and death through toxic and radioactive contamination.” We strongly condemn the contentions of merchants of nuclear death who are very active these days crying hoarse about the ‘clean, cheap and green’ nuclear energy even after the 3-mile-island and Chernobyl disasters. Though not a single nuclear reactor has been installed in US since 1979, they are unabashedly offering 6-8 nuclear reactors to India and eventually our ‘smiling Buddha’ would only leave behind a ‘wailing Indica’. All friends of humanity – no matter whether right, left or centre in politics – in India or anywhere in the world – have to come forward to condemn such mad proliferation campaigns. ¨¨¨