Tuesday, November 2, 2021

Editorial, "TRUTH TELLING MUST NOT BE CRIMINALIZED," in LAW ANIMATED WORLD, Vol. 17, Part 1, No. 11, 15 JUNE 2021 issue


 TRUTH TELLING MUST NOT BE CRIMINALIZED

YES, and especially in these worldwide Corona Crisis days when so many disturbing tragic phenomena are occurring, and governments possessing excessive powers are misleading the people with deceptive measures and untruthful propaganda, different sorts of truth speaking by scholars and social activists is quite essential to protect and promote the basic right to life of the people. In this context it was quite heartening to watch Engineer Mallik exposing the many loopholes/faults in the governments’/institutions’ policies and measures in this regard, on several YouTube videos, and learning so many new things from that. As such this editor was shocked at the news of the Director of Public Health, Telangana, filing a criminal complaint against the ‘false information’ spread by Mallik, “an individual [with] no official training in epidemiology or medical science, yet ... continued to spread panic, who allegedly said on the [TV] show[s] that one person from every household would die in the third wave, averring that “in these testing times, spreading of rumors by P Mallik, which are unfounded and do not have any scientific backing, will definitely cause panic and distress among the common man. ......". It seems the Sultan Bazar P.S. has booked a case against Mr Paruchuri Mallik under S. 54 of the Disaster Management Act 2005 {Punishment for false warning: (punishable with 1 year imprisonment or fine)} and S. 505 of the IPC {Statements conducing to public mischief: (punishable with 3 years’ imprisonment or fine or both)}. This is nothing but severe harassment and vilification of a whistleblower who has honestly warned the public about the impending calamity. If this is taken as OK, then what one should say about the WHO Director-General Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus, who  stated (on 26-04-2021) that the Covid-19 (second wave) situation in India was “beyond heartbreaking” and about the British Government caused modelling report, which alerted about the third wave of COVID-19 spike that could kill/hospitalize 60-70% of the people who took both the vaccine doses even; or of the Nobel laureate virologist Monsieur Luc Montagnier who declared that ‘mass vaccination [for Covid-19] is a [unacceptable] medical mistake” and was even said to have warned about lakhs of deaths in future. We strongly feel that such criminal proceedings are but a stern suppression, by devious means, of the fundamental right to freedom of speech and expression of the people and demand that those be withdrawn or be quashed by a competent court forthwith. §§§



No comments: